Medicare,
simplified —
by neighbors.
Free, no-pressure Medicare guidance for seniors in New Jersey, parts of Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. We compare every plan in your area and give you a straight answer — the one we'd give our own parents.
- Cost to you
- $0
- Carriers compared
- 16+
- Local clients
- 3,000+
"Melissa explained every detail. She helped me pick the right plan for my needs."
— Debra, Woodbury NJ
What we help with
Everything Medicare. Nothing else.
We focus only on Medicare — so we know it inside out. From your first enrollment to your tenth annual review, we make sure your plan still fits your life.
Medicare Advantage
All-in-one plans that often include dental, vision, and prescription coverage. We compare every option in your zip code.
Medicare Supplements
Medigap plans that fill the gaps Original Medicare leaves behind — and give you the freedom to see any doctor who accepts Medicare.
Part D Prescription Plans
We match your exact medication list to the plan that costs you the least each year — pharmacy by pharmacy.
Annual Plan Reviews
Plans change every year. We check yours every fall and tell you, plainly, whether to switch or stay.
How it works
Three simple steps. No pressure, ever.
- 01
Call or message us
A real person from our New Jersey office answers — usually on the first ring.
- 02
Meet however you like
Phone, video, our Woodbury office, or your kitchen table. No pressure, no sales pitch.
- 03
Get a clear recommendation
We walk you through your options in plain English and help you enroll — only if you want to.
Customer appreciation events
Come say hello — coffee's on us.
We host free events across New Jersey throughout the year. Bring your Medicare card and a question — leave with answers (and often a gift card to a local favorite like Heritage's).
Meet your local agents
Real people, right down the road.
Our agents live and work in the same communities you do. Office, home, or phone — whatever's easiest for you.
Melissa
"I treat every client like family — because around here, you probably know my family."
Joe Craig
"My job is to make Medicare make sense — so you can stop worrying and get back to living."
"Melissa was the best. She explained every little detail that I needed to know and helped me pick the right plan to fit my needs. I'd recommend The Senior Store to anyone."
— Debra, New Jersey client
Companies we represent
16+ top-rated carriers, one honest recommendation.
- AARP
- United Healthcare
- Aetna
- Amerigroup
- Amerihealth
- CIGNA
- Clover
- Humana
- Mutual of Omaha
- SilverScript
- Transamerica
- WellCare
- Foresters
- Midland
- National
- William Penn
Get a free Medicare review
Let's find the plan that actually fits.
Office, home, or phone — whatever's easiest. Free, with no obligation to enroll. We'll listen first, then explain your options.
Call our local office
856-520-0678
Toll free
877-852-7665 (877-ULEARN65)